The Honourable Baldwin Spencer, Prime Minister of
Antigua and Barbuda
Chairman, the Honourable Harold Lovell, Minister of
Finance, of Antigua and Barbuda and other Ministers
of Government
Ambassador Valeriano Diaz, Head of the Delegation of
the European Union to Barbados and the Eastern
Caribbean
Governor of the Eastern Caribbean Central Bank Sir K
Dwight Venner
Representatives of International and Regional
Organisations
Representatives of CARIFORUM Member States and
Associate Members
Representatives of the Private Sector
Assistant Secretary General Irwin La Rocque and
staff of the CARICOM Secretariat including the
CARIFORUM Directorate
Representatives of the Media
Distinguished Ladies and Gentlemen
As Secretary-General of CARIFORUM, the Caribbean
Forum of African Caribbean Pacific (ACP) States, it
is with pleasure - and not a little exhaustion –
that I address you this morning. This meeting comes
less than two days after the 31st Meeting of the
Conference of Heads of Government of the Caribbean
Community held in Montego Bay, Jamaica, which as you
would expect required significant mental and
physical energy.
However, my presence here today is testimony to
my appreciation of the importance of Financial
Services and indeed, of the entire services sector
to the Caribbean. The services sector accounts for
more than 70 percent of the gross domestic product
of most countries of the Region.
I therefore wish to take this opportunity to
thank the Commission of the European Union for
co-sponsoring this conference with the CARIFORUM
countries. I must also express the Region’s
appreciation to the Honourable Baldwin Spencer,
Prime Minister of Antigua and Barbuda, Lead Head of
Government with responsibility for Services in the
Quasi-Cabinet of CARICOM Heads of Government, for
initiating the actions which have led to the holding
of this very important Joint CARIFORUM/EU
Conference.
I also wish to thank the many international and
regional agencies, for agreeing to participate in
what I feel confident will be a successful
conference.
Mr Chairman, this conference comes at a most
opportune time for the Caribbean Region. It will
allow the Region to review the current status of its
Financial Services Sector, describe the challenges
faced and assess the demands which will be made on
the regulatory environment in the Region. The
conference will also afford the chance to explore
how the Caribbean can convert the existing
challenges into opportunities, not least in the
continuing efforts at economic diversification in
the Region.
It was with that diversification in mind that, in
the 1980s, International Financial Institutions (IFIs)
encouraged countries in the Caribbean to promote
international financial services as a mechanism for
economic diversification, income and employment
generation and growth. A number of our Caribbean
countries has become successful in implementing that
policy initiative
However, over the last ten or so years, the very
success deriving from the pursuit of that policy
prescription has attracted negative attention of
certain institutions including the Organisation of
Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD). In this
case success seems to have attracted more punishment
than reward.
There seems to exist the perception that
successful international financial centres are
havens for tax evasion and tax avoidance. Following
the OECD 1998 Report on “Harmful Tax Competition: An
Emerging Global Issue” which described the
identifying and contributory characteristics of what
was termed ‘tax havens’, Caribbean countries have
had to subscribe to the OECD Model Tax Convention.
In so doing they had to make amendments to their
legislation and practices relating to international
financial and banking activities and strengthen
their network of double taxation treaties. This was
all in an attempt to remove themselves from a
blacklist, compiled by the OECD, which sought to
name, shame and punish those countries that did not
comply with the requirements of the OECD.
But that was not all. The goal posts were shifted
from time to time. Apart from ‘committing’ to the
OECD imposed tax standard, Caribbean jurisdictions
were required to show a certain degree of compliance
by signing at least twelve (12) Tax Information
Exchange Agreements (TIEAs) with major capital
suppliers - all of this at the height of the global
financial and economic crisis. By July 2010, the
vast majority of the CARIFORUM international
financial jurisdictions were able to do so.
Mr Chairman, the Caribbean has therefore been
engaged in a continuous struggle to secure a level
playing field in developments related to
international financial services. The Caribbean
Association of Regulators of International Business,
followed by the International Tax and Investment
Organisation, with headquarters in Barbados, was at
the forefront of that effort.
Despite those attempts, Caribbean jurisdictions
are still treated less favourably than, for example,
certain European jurisdictions for identical
circumstances.
The OECD countries continue to put pressure on
corporations in their jurisdictions with
subsidiaries in International Financial Centres. In
this regard, Caribbean jurisdictions will find
themselves coming under increasing scrutiny.
All of these developments continue to have
negative implications for the Caribbean. Entities
which might have been licensed, incorporated or
registered in the Caribbean are taking their
business elsewhere. Some others already located in
the Caribbean are departing. The in-depth and
comprehensive monitoring and peer review, decided by
the September 2009 Global Forum Meeting in Mexico,
will create further problems for Caribbean
jurisdictions. Unless that negative trend can be
reversed, Caribbean economies will face tougher
challenges to maintain jobs, earn income and
generate foreign exchange from the sector.
From a regional perspective, joint actions and
strategies and the operation of joint and common
institutions provide the most effective means of
developing and strengthening the Region’s financial
services sector. Such action also constitute the
most viable mechanism for dealing with some of these
global developments, including the negative
perceptions which some may have of the industry in
the Caribbean. These institutions include the
following:
(i) The Caribbean Association of Insurance
Regulators (ii) The Caribbean Group of Bank
Supervisors (iii) The Caribbean Group of Securities
Regulators; and (iv) The CARICOM Committee of
Central Bank Governors.
These together with a ‘Caribbean College of
Regulators’ would go a long way in addressing the
credibility of the regulatory environment in the
Caribbean for Financial Services.
As part of our commitment to deepen regional
integration in the financial services sector, the
Caribbean Community has a Financial Services
Agreement under consideration. That Agreement is
intended to give effect to the provisions of Chapter
Three of the Revised Treaty of Chaguaramas. It would
create a single financial space with common
legislation, regulations, administrative procedures
and practices. It provides for cross border
supervision and harmonisation of standards.
Against this background of the Caribbean’s
commitment and its actions to set high standards in
the financial services sector, it is heartening to
see representatives from so many regional and
international agencies and organisations coming
together over the next two days to assist in this
process. I especially want to thank the European
Union for its financial and technical contribution
to this Forum. I must also thank the World Bank, the
International Monetary Fund, the Inter-American
Development Bank as well as the OECD, Caribbean
Central Bankers - including the ECCB -, the
Caribbean Development Bank, the University of the
West Indies, CARTAC and the Financial Action Task
Force for their willingness to share their expertise
over the next two days.
It is with that sense of knowledge sharing, that
I want to wish this conference every success as we
seek to ensure that this Region has the opportunity
to give its citizens a more than equal chance to
build a viable and prosperous society.
I thank you for the opportunity to make these
hopefully relevant remarks at the opening of this
timely important conference.