I welcome and congratulate, too, the
Honourable Dr. Lowell Lewis on his election to the
Office of Chief Minister of Montserrat, and the Most
Honourable Portia Simpson-Miller, my very dear
friend, on her elevation to the Prime Ministership
of Jamaica, the Land we all love! This is no
Shakespearean Portia, towering as that figure has
been among merchants in Venice. Our Portia is
destiny’s child in the finest Jamaican tradition of
Nanny, Garvey, Bogle, Gordon, Bustamante, the
Manleys, and Patterson. The Caribbean Region yearns
for Portia’s dynamic leadership. In paraphrasing
Kevin Lyttle’s international, mega-hit song, I am
sure that, politically-speaking, Portia will turn us
on.
I thank the people of St. Vincent and the
Grenadines for providing the Unity Labour Party and
me, yet again, with an overwhelming mandate in our
recent general elections. Central to that mandate is
the further deepening of the institutional political
expression of our Caribbean civilisation, and the
soonest practical elaboration of the CARICOM Single
Market and Economy (CSME).
At this august assembled gathering, we, the
political leaders of the Caribbean Community who are
servants of the people are called to be apostles of
a deeper, more perfect Caribbean union. History and
geography pre-dispose our nation-states to combine;
harsh and compelling contemporary realities resident
in the social economy of our respective countries,
and their unequal and constricting yoke to the
international political economy, produce
circumstances which induce us to a deeper, more
profound integration.
Criss-crossing these pre-disposing and inducing
factors, which together constitute an unanswerable
case for a deeper union, are a veritable
parallelogram of forces, "islandness", real national
or domestic self-interest, vanities, and even
accidents which always threaten to undermine the
efficacy of the regional enterprise but never quite
do so. The subversion or derailing of this modern
integration enterprise of the Indies never ever
takes place because the fundamentals, material and
existential, are, in the final analysis, too deeply
rooted. In the end, we always see the illuminating
stars of a beneficial integration and hear the
rolling thunder of its immense possibilities,
despite its worrying limitations.
St. Vincent and the Grenadines and other
Member States of the Organisation of Eastern
Caribbean States (OECS) have agreed to accede to the
CARICOM Single Market, consonant with their
earlier commitment. The vital concerns of the OECS
member states have been satisfactorily addressed, or
are in the process of being suitably resolved. The
quartet of fundamental OECS issues have been: First,
the practical elaboration of the Development Fund
under Article 158 of the Revised Treaty of
Chaguaramas for Disadvantaged countries, regions and
sectors; secondly, the clarification of the scope of
the "access to land" obligation under the Revised
Treaty and its compatibility with the existing
Aliens Landholding Licensing Regime; thirdly, the
broadening and deepening of the freedom of movement
of persons within the Single Market area; and fourthly, the
fashioning of a Regional Stock Exchange upon the
base of the highly-sophisticated Stock Exchange
platform in the Eastern Caribbean Currency Union (ECCU).
No one should ever doubt the commitment of the
OECS Member States to a deeper and more perfect
union in the Caribbean. Indeed, the proof of the
pudding is in the eating: the OECS is a far more
tightly-drawn integration effort than CARICOM. Among
other things, the OECS has its own currency union,
its own currency - stable and strong for over 25
years - its own integrated Court system; and last
week, its leaders signed a Letter of Intent to adopt
an Economic Union Treaty within twelve months, a
draft of which Treaty includes altered regional
governance arrangements of a far-reaching kind which
certain other members of the wider CARICOM have
signaled no willingness to entertain. It is
imperative that, at the propitious time, this OECS
Economic Union Treaty be accorded formal recognition
by the wider CARICOM.
So, in real terms, the OECS is in the vanguard
not the rearguard, of the regional integration
movement. It is not unreasonable that its
Member States seek to protect or advance the
interests of their nationals and to clarify matters
of concern. Indeed, the other members of CARICOM
fully accept our duty so to do, and many, in fact, have
assisted us in so doing. A reflective sensitivity to
our challenges has been helpful.
The approach by the OECS is right, just and
proper. There has been a noise in our blood and an
echo in our bone which has a resonance from the
early days of Christendom. Paul in 1 Corinthians
(Chapter 12) puts it thus:
"And the eye cannot say unto the hand, I have no
need of thee; nor again the head to the feet, I have
no need of you.
"Nay, much more those members of the
body, which seem to be more feeble, are necessary:
"And those members of the body, which we think to be
less honourable, upon these we bestow more abundant
honour; and our uncomely parts have more abundant
comeliness.
"…….That there should be no schism in
the body; but that the members should have the same
care for another.
"And, whether one member suffer,
all the members suffer with it; or one member be honoured,
all the members rejoice with it."
Clearly, all this is relevant not only to the
fragile OECS and Belize but also to a Highly
Indebted Poor Country like Guyana.
It is this Pauline teaching of “special and
differential treatment” and the organic unity of the
one body which, I am sure, has been moving the
out-going Chairman of CARICOM, the Honourable
Patrick Manning, among other leaders in the wider
CARICOM, to act always with a generosity of spirit,
with wisdom and foresight.
If the truth be properly told, the CARICOM Single
Market holds far fewer practical benefits for
the OECS member-countries than would a deeper form
of economic integration, appropriately articulated
in practice. St. Vincent and the Grenadines
therefore looks forward to the transition of the CARICOM Single Market
to the CARICOM Single Market and Economy.
Difficult issues lay ahead but they are not
incapable of resolution, satisfactory to all
concerned.
Mr. Chairman, Colleague Heads, recently, I was
re-reading a remarkable book entitled The Conscience
of Words and Earwitness by the distinguished
European Nobel Laureate for Literature, Elias
Canetti. He wrote something which is very apt, at
this juncture, for our integration movement. I want
to share it:
"Among the most sinister phenomena in
intellectual history is the avoidance of the
concrete. People have had a conscious tendency
to go first after the most remote things,
ignoring everything that they stumble over close
by. The élan of outgoing gestures, the boldness
and adventure of expeditions to faraway places
camouflage their motives. The not infrequent
goal is to avoid what lies near because we are
not up to it. We sense danger and prefer other
and unknown perils. Even when these are found —
and they are always found — they still have the
glow of the sudden and the unique. One would
have to be very narrow-minded to condemn this
adventurousness of the mind even though it
sometimes comes from obvious weaknesses. It has
led to an expansion of our horizon, of which we
are proud. But the situation of mankind today,
as we all know, is so serious that we have to
turn to what is closest and most concrete!"
The concrete and practical matters which are
closest to us include: poverty, unemployment,
underdevelopment, a lack of economic
competitiveness, lifestyle diseases, the
environmental consequences of climate change,
natural disasters, fiscal deficits, democratic
governance, relative technological limitations, the
fall-out from modern globalisation and trade
liberalisation, a debilitating cultural imperialism
including from the ghettoes of some American cities,
a political intolerance derived from partisan
political divisiveness, official corruption, and
heightened criminal activities.
CARICOM and the CSME are intended to assist in
successfully meeting these challenges, not to slow
down, encumber, or in any way limit the Member Countries in their efforts to lift the quality of
peoples' lives. Accordingly, a narrow, legalistic
approach to the Revised Treaty, or a less than a
robustly liberal and purposive interpretation of its
provisions, would likely sound the CSME's death bell,
if, in the process, it blocks legitimate national
expressions. Further, a Single Market, a Single
Economy or other form of deeper union, cannot
properly be pursued if it underpins representative
government, or if it seeks to impose an impatient
beginning through an insensitive regional
bureaucracy, or a sense of regional superiority by
some, which would undoubtedly rankle.
The answers to these challenges do not reside in
the purely technical. Indeed, purely technocratic
emphases, devoid of strategic approaches and
philosophical clarity grounded in the concrete
realities, will lead our Region towards a transition
to a dead-end.
Too often, a quest for transformative strategies,
and the removal of ideational cobwebs in our search
for appropriate solutions, is resisted by entrenched
political and economic interests nationally, and
their allies across the Region and beyond. The late
revered William Demas alerted us to all this in his
seminal essay in 1990 entitled Towards West Indian
Survival. In the process, Demas identified three
economic options for our Region:
(1) Scenario A: The continued inability to
generate sufficient internal dynamics for growth and
development by pursuing wholly or largely national
approaches through this or that adjustment programme.
(2) Scenario B: Heightened external dependence
and absorption. This is the inevitable consequence
of Scenario A.
(3) Scenario C: An internal dynamic for growth
and development and a viable competitive economy
through a deepening of CARICOM into a Regional
Economy.
This latter option is what the CSME is about!
Now that the CARICOM Single Market is a reality, let us consolidate
it and move with expedition and commitment to a
workable and productive CSME, consistent with the
Revised Treaty.
In doing so, I suggest that we resist the embrace
of learned helplessness which is repeatedly fed to
the people of our Region by too many politicians,
opinion-makers, intellectuals, public officials,
bureaucrats of one kind or another, business
managers, development partners, and even prelates
whose religious doctrines, ironically, are based on
optimism and redemption. The antidote to learned
helplessness is an optimism grounded in the
uplifting ethos and spirit of our Caribbean civilisation, and which drives the necessity and
desirability of a political virtuousness as the
cornerstone for individual and collective
self-mastery.
This quest for individual and collective
self-mastery in the interest of our own humanisation,
demands, among other things, hard and smart work;
discipline; a social organisation of labour which
produces and rewards; a nobility of purpose; the
igniting and enhancing of our creativity of mind and
spirit; the lifting not only of degree but of
pedigree, including that of the folk; and a
thorough-going historical reclamation. And we can,
and must, succeed, in this our own monumental
Enterprise of the Indies. Our history, our folk
wisdom, our peculiar Caribbean genius, make it near
impossible to fail.
Our Region has endured, survived, and thrived
through a systematic genocide of its indigenous
peoples, a brutal slavery of the African ancestors
of our Caribbean family, and the dehumanising
indentureship of those of our forebears who hailed
from China, India, and the Iberian Peninsula or its
neighbouring islands. This Caribbean Region has
triumphed over colonialism, and is continuing to
resist neo-colonalism and imperialism. Yet, despite
the crimes against humanity committed against us, and
the suffering imposed upon us by other nations, we
have held, to our everlasting credit, our hands of
friendship and humanity towards those who have hurt
us.
They have not apologised with true contrition to
us as they have done to others; and they have not
offered reparations as some of them have done
elsewhere to other peoples who have suffered less or
similarly. On the contrary, some seem to be drunk on
an arrogant triumphalism. These are live issues and
ought not to be ducked as we go forward with them in
partnership. It is not that I am looking forward to
the past; it is that hurtling to the future demands
at least an assuaging of the past hurts. To be sure,
of all time, only the future is ours to desecrate,
but the present is the past; and the past is full of mischiefs which resonate in the present.
Our master poet from St. Vincent and the
Grenadines, Shake Keane, provides a fitting
inspiration to our Caribbean people in his poem
entitled "Private Prayer" written in 1973 for the
late Walter Rodney at the time of the publication of
Rodney's epoch-making "How Europe Underdeveloped
Africa":
"To understand
How the whole thing run
I have to
ask my parents
And even my daughter and son
"To understand the form
Of compromise I am
I must
in my own voice ask
How the whole thing run
"To ask
Why I don’t dream
In the language I live
in
I must rise up
Among syllables of my parents
In
the land which I am
"And from
A whole daughter a whole son
Out of the
compromise
Which I am
"To understand history
I have to come home."
Part of our home-coming is CARICOM and the CSME.
Others may help us, but we are the ones who must all
be the main productive hands on deck. It is we, the
Caribbean people of all walks of life, who know our
Region and its possibilities better than anyone
else. It is us - the leaders of all kinds, and the
people as an integrated whole in communion with
their leaders - who must bring the touching poetic
majesty of Derek Walcott to life and living over the
pastures of bananas and sugar cane, where our
countries lift their respective horns, sunrise
trickles down the valleys, the waves wash along the
beaches, blood splashes on the cedars, and the
grooves flood with the light of sacrifice.
This historic gathering calls for a remembrance
of the giants of the integration movement from
across the ages and the Region. I celebrate them.
Because of their life and work it remains possible
to glimpse morning before the sun; possible to see
early where sunset might stain anticipated night.
The tongue of memory records the hurt at any of
their regional failures, but it extols, too, the
magnificence of their efforts in helping to fashion
the architectural dream and reality which we hold
aloft today.
Assembled today are leaders who, in one way or
another, contributed immensely to this CARICOM
Single Market
enterprise thus far. But none has been more
tireless, unsparing and inspirational in his efforts
than my dear colleague, Owen Seymour Arthur, Prime
Minister of Barbados and our colleague Head who has
the lead responsibility for the CSME. Owen, you have
enhanced our political virtue and our quest for
individual and collective self-mastery. You have
given meaning to Martin Carter’s poetic summation of
our painful and joyous historic journey by ensuring
that we who have come from yesterday with our
limiting burdens have now turned to the world of
tomorrow with our considerable strengths.
On 1 January 2007, I will, God willing, assume
the rotational Chairmanship of CARICOM. I pledge, as
always, to advance further the interests of our
Caribbean civilization.
Thank you and may Almighty God continue to bless
us all!