In considering the purposes to be served by this
Symposium, we may wish to reflect on an observation
by George Lamming:
“The architecture of our future is not
only unfinished; the scaffolding has hardly gone
up”.
It must be a matter for some gratification that
over the past 18 months there has been more evidence
than in the past of a determination to carry forward
the work to bring A Single CARICOM Market and
Economy into existence.
The Caribbean Court of Justice (CCJ) has been
created to give greater certainty and predictability
to the application of the policies and programmes
which will constitute the core of the regional
economic integration process.
Six countries representing the MDC component of
the proposed new regional economy have made
themselves compliant with the requirements to
constitute themselves to be part of the Single
Market.
Last week, in Barbados, a historic decision was
made by the regional private sector to form itself
into a more representative body as the CARICOM
Business Council. Should it work, as intended, a new
powerful instrument of governance would have been
called into existence to help us plan, and to
oversee the implementation of the proposed Single
Economy.
A week ago we agreed also, in principle, on the
contribution formula for the proposed regional
Development Fund. This provided a glimmer of hope
that the programme of special and differential
treatment, within a CSME, for our lesser developed
members can be brought into existence, and these
countries can proceed to walk within the CSME,
guided by sight rather than by faith.
Despite the evidence of progress, we must
maintain a realistic sense of proportion as to what
has thus far been achieved, and what now remains to
be accomplished.
The new Caribbean Court of Justice can hardly be
described as being excessively busy. Realistically,
the justice the Court is capable of dispensing is
immediately being accessed by only two of its
members.
The launch of the Caribbean Single Market,
important as it is, carries with it all of the
strengths, but also all of the limitations of the
Market as the means by which development can be
induced.
In our case, the programme for the liberalization
of the trade in goods preceded the CSME, and much of
the programme for the liberalization of the
provision and trade in services has generally been
ingrained in most Caribbean economies as part of new
macro-economic directions that have been pursued
since the late 1980’s. They are not new. Similarly,
the liberalization of capital flows and transactions
by CARICIN States not only preceded the CSME but
owed as much to precepts promoted by the Washington
Consensus as to any very indigenous ideology of
Caribbean development.
The major decisive difference that the coming
into existence of the Single Market in and of itself
will make will arise from its provisions for labour
mobility – something that was not contemplated in
preceding forms of integration in the region, nor in
any other set of economic policies used in modern
times to influence the course of Caribbean
development.
Regrettably, the enormous potential of labour
mobility to drive Caribbean development, by enabling
us to access a regional pool of labour and skills to
build more competitive enterprises, sectors and
national economies, is being undermined by a fierce
xenophobia across the Region.
The creation of a Single CARICOM Market is thus a
necessary but not a sufficient condition to conduce
regional economic development.
We are very near to church, but still far from
God. But we must persevere. The substantial benefits
from economic integration will in fact derive from
the construction of a Single Regional Economy.
Those benefits will ensue from the integration of
our production systems, and the rationalization of
the use of all of our resources associated
therewith. They will come from the full integration
and harmonized development of our financial capital
market; the coordinated development of our region’s
transport and communications networks; the creation
of a new enterprise culture in Caricom by the
harmonization of our policies relating to
investments, incentives and macro economic policies
in general.
It was in recognition of the fact that the
creation of the CSM represents only a start that a
mandate was sought and received from Caricom Heads
that we should accelerate the development of the
framework for the Single Economy and have it agreed
and ready to be implemented, beginning in 2008.
This confers a high strategic significance as
well as an imposing sense of urgency on the
proceedings of this Symposium. On
its outcome hangs the effective transition from the
Single Market to a full fledged Single Regional
Economy, and with it the realization of the true
transformation dynamics that economic integration
can bring to bear in regional development.
The realization of such beneficial effects from
integration will however require more than the
successful outcome of this Symposium.
I will not make light of the quite considerable
challenges that respective Caribbean States
experience in meeting their Treaty obligations to be
part of the CSME. But those obligations
were not imposed on us by any colonial master nor
any supranational extra-regional institution. They
were negotiated in good faith and agreed by the
respective countries in their capacity as sovereign
States.
In that sense they reflect and embody the
exercise of our sovereignty in pursuit of higher
levels of domestic and regional achievement.
It becomes impossible to establish any kind of
relationship of lasting value if countries, on their
own volition, enter treaties and then find reasons
not to comply with them.
I can this morning safely say that those of us
who have responsibilities to facilitate the creation
of the CSME – and mine have been onerous - have been
sparing no effort to ensure our CSME does not emerge
as a permanent coalition of unequals.
There is also a Caribbean genius on which we must
continue to draw, to accommodate the special
circumstances of individual cases, and to accept
nuance and flexibility in the way in which the best
conceived designs are applied in the real world.
This, however, does not create a licence for
individual states to seek to impose on the
implementation of a regional programme, which was
negotiated and agreed by all in good faith,
unilateral conditions which go beyond the spirit and
scope of the Treaty which binds us.
Realistically, therefore, there are issues
surrounding the participation of the OECS countries
in the CSME which constitute a challenge which must
be sensitively and sensibly met on all sides.
The Caribbean Community was also created to
promote sustained and equitable regional development
through three forms of integration - economic
integration, functional cooperation and the
coordination of our external economic relations and
foreign polic. The move to build the CSME has
galvanized our regional economic integration
process.
There has, however, been no corresponding great
leap forward in the conception, design and
implementation of the regional functional
cooperation programme.
In its absence, issues regarding the distribution
of benefits from economic integration, per se,
are likely to become highly and sharply divisive.
The time is therefore appropriate to look again,
in a more holistic way, at the relationship between
the processes of Caribbean integration to bring the
economic, social and governance dimensions not only
into balance, but to create a creative and
harmonious fusion in their workings in pursuit of
equitable development.
These are new times.
Cometh the hour, cometh the ideas. Even at this
early stage, it is clear that the form and extent of
economic integration we are seeking to establish in
our Region cannot draw blindly from the experience
of others and requires intellectual ferment and
creative reflection.
I merely illustrate by drawing on one example.
Europe created a Regional Development Fund to
which access was restricted to its lesser developed
countries, using per capita income levels as the
dividing line. In the Caribbean, the country with
the highest per capita income is regarded as an LDC
within CARICOM. The two with the lowest per
capital income are classified as MDC’s.
How do you structure the formation and operation
of a regional Development Fund intended to transfer
resources from the better off to those in greatest
need in such a context?
In the late 1960’s and early 1970’s, the initial
attempts at economic integration inspired an
outpouring of advice and reflection from some of the
best minds in the Region.
The character of the integration process that is
contemplated to be implemented in the first decades
of the 21st century goes radically beyond anything
that was conceived then, and must be made the
subject of the most creative enquiry.
This Conference is intended to provide an
environment for such enquiry and engagement, to
enable us to set the stage to carry our regional
economy to a higher stage of accomplishment.
The Government of Barbados is greatly pleased to
be able to offer the place and environment within
which this Symposium can take place, especially on
the eve of a Heads of Government Conference.
I wish to be your effective advocate on that
occasion.
I therefore look forward to the results of this
Symposium, and to be able to report on them to my
colleague Heads of Government as having achieved the
purpose intended.